OBSERVER Photo by M.J. Stafford Recovery Real Estate Holdings, LLC purchased the former Grossman’s Bargain Outlet in January. The company is putting a Green Mountain Electric Supply at this location.

A vacant warehouse in the city of Dunkirk was sold for millions of dollars

The Post-Journal and OBSERVER have been analyzing real estate sales in Chautauqua County and recently looked at the sales from the first two weeks of January.

During that time period, Allegany-Erie Inc. of Dunkirk sold 211 West Point Ave., Dunkirk to West Grove Road, LLC of Oradell, NJ for $2.4 million. The warehouse had been advertised on line as a “well maintained 104,000 sq ft. warehouse/distribution asset, continually operated by one tenant for 18 years.”

The real estate listing noted the building is on a 13.9 acre lot “with capacity for building expansion.”

It does not appear there is anyone there at the current time.

There was a second large sale in the town of Dunkirk. 84 Bennett Enterprise Inc. of Fredonia sold 10749 Bennett Road, Dunkirk to Recovery Real Estate Holdings LLC of Colchester, Vermont for $650,000. The sale includes two parcels.

This is the former Grossman’s Bargain Outlet which closed possibly 20 years ago. The building opened in the 1990s as an 84 Lumber.

A sign for Green Mountain Electric Supply is now on the new building. Recovery Real Estate Holdings LLC also owns a Green Mountain Electric Supply location in Jamestown.

From Jan. 3-13, there were 10 sales that were $250,000 or higher.

The remaining eight sales were as follows:

¯ 84 North Lake LLC of Cleveland, Ohio sold 84 North Lake Drive, Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua to Mollie Baker Merchant for $2.4 million. This is described as a four bedroom, four bath, 3,478 square foot residence.

¯ 4th and Pine Development, LLC of Jamestown sold 9-25 East 4th St., Jamestown to Jamestown Office Reality LLC, Jamestown Hakimian LLC and Jamestown Nitzani LLC of Great Neck, NY for $800,000. This is known in Jamestown as the 4th and Pine Professional Building, with multiple businesses in it, including Nouveau Salon and Day Spa, Express Employment Professionals, law offices, and more.

¯ 1876 Big Tree Road, Busti sold for $725,000.

¯ 78387 Clymer Center Road, Clymer sold for $350,000.

¯ 26 S. Terrace Ave., Chautauqua Institution, Chautauqua town sold for $331,000.

¯ 16 and 18 Front St., Silver Creek sold for $322,000.

¯ 5588 South Ave., Van Buren Point, town of Portland, sold to for $292,000.

¯ 5 parcels on Rt. 20, Portland were sold to Agriamerica LLC of Silver Creek for $280,000.

During this time period, there were 132 transactions total, with 81 of them higher than $1.

The full list of transactions higher than $1 are as follows:

Samuel Gullotti, Alfred Gullotti, Susan Bishop and Sharon Tefft sold 9 Logan Ave., Jamestown to R.J. Mead, Inc. of Jamestown for $175,000.

Jessica Vara sold 42 Seel St., Dunkirk to Candice Lopez for $99,000.

Brett and Amy Muscarella sold 125 Emory Dr., Jamestown to Timothy and Nannette Doolittle for $226,000.

The executors for Carolyn Widmark sold 1412 Riverside Road, Carroll to Wayne Haney for $117,021.

Celeste Lira, Timothy Rosengarten and Mary Jayne Mulroy sold 2481 Lakeside Drive, Busti to Timothy and Jaime Bell for $245,000.

Edward Hubennette sold 1876 Big Tree Road, Busti to Brian and Siobhan Dowdall for $725,000.

The executor for the estate of Allan D. Hendrickson sold 507 W. 8th St., Jamestown to Brian and Kimberlee Taylor for $36,000.

Mark and Karen Shaw sold 5323 Van Buren Bay Road, Pomfret to Louise Decosta-Bacher for $55,000.

The executrix of the estate of Timothy Nowell sold 230 E. Falconer St., Falconer to Anthony and Michelle Marra for $35,000.

Mildred Brooks, Thadford Brooks, Charles Brooks, Carl Brooks, and Doris Taylor sold 2218 Rt. 39, Sheridan to Jeanette and Mark Vaughn for $40,000.

Cassadaga Class B Holdings, LLC of Pittsburgh, Pa. sold 6947 Rt. 60, Charlotte to Legacy and Legend Holdings, LLC of Cassadaga for $200,000.

John and Cynthia Olson sold 330 Delaware Ave., Jamestown to Mathew Cardinale for $82,680.

Harriett Minnigh sold 26 S. Terrace Ave., Chautauqua Institution, Chautauqua town to Alpha CHQ, LLC of Brookfield, Wis., for $331,000.

Ronald and Mary Miller sold 426 Eagle St., Dunkirk to Jeasmar Hernandez Sanchez for $127,000.

4th and Pine Development, LLC of Jamestown sold 9-25 East 4th St., Jamestown to Jamestown Office Reality LLC, Jamestown Hakimian LLC and Jamestown Nitzani LLC of Great Neck, NY for $800,000.

Fae Southworth sold 2050 Main Road, Sheridan, to Lori Taber for $50,000.

Yu Property Management LLC of Jamestown sold 27 Mapleview Ave., Lakewood to Francine Roffwarg and Maxine Perchuk for $210,000.

Richard Wight and Robert Wight sold property on Westman Road, Ellery to Sean and Carrie Egan for $27,000.

Dennis and Joan Barrus sold 3115 Strunk Road, Ellicott to Brenda Smith, Deborah Swanson, Timothy Barrus and Denise Stuard for $170,000.

David Zielinski sold 29 Susan Court, Fredonia to Kathleen Krystofik for $110,000.

Steven St. George sold Lot 33, Ryan Place, Fredonia to Cathy Crocker for $29,000.

James Walter sold 534 Robbin Hill Road, Frewsburg, town of Carroll to Tayler Fortune for $122,000.

Pomfret Estates Inc. of Boca Raton, Fla. sold five parcels near Chestnut Street, Fredonia to RIC New York LLC of New York City for $139,080.

The executors of the Last Will and Testament of Grace Meyers sold 11555 Hanover Road, Hanover to Susanne Wilgos-Torcasio and David Edward Moyer for $55,000.

Simon and Kathryn Lee sold 1904 Clymer Hill Road, Clymer to Nathan Troyer for $105,000.

Edward and Virginia Persons sold 78387 Clymer Center Road, Clymer to Daniel and Ruthie Burkholder for $350,000.

Joyce Boedo sold 419 Christy Road, Hanover to Daniel Damian for $182,500.

Nathan Smith sold 7 Cushing St., Fredonia to JK Meech Homes LLC of Buffalo for $54,000.

Harry Daniel Kopf III sold 22 W. Main St., Frewsburg, town of Carroll to Frewsburg W&S LLC of Frewsburg for $40,000.

The administrator of the Estate of Richard Nelson sold 82 W. Mosher St., Ellicott to Hanna Tibbitts for $90,000.

Corey and Kera Coleson sold 11 Howard St., Carroll, to Shelby Surrena for $80,000.

Ross Sorci sold 12 Woodcrest Drive, Fredonia to Andrea Deceilio for $170,000.

Frank and Joanne Semelka sold property on West Side Hill Road, Ripley to the Semelka Family 2020 Irrevocable Trust of North East, Pa. for $200,000.

Tammi Smith sold 2564 Rt. 20, Sheridan to Matthew Ligammari for $74,200.

Linda Corell sold 5 parcels on Rt. 20, Portland to Agriamerica LLC of Silver Creek for $280,000.

Jake Lundquist and Lindsey Beckstrom sold 4716 Ashville Road, Busti to David and Carrie Munsee for $38,157.

Florence Turner sold 1442 East Main St., Sherman to P&P Fisher Family Trust of Sherman for $700.

Charles Winters sold 11 Eagle St., Forestville, town of Hanover, to Kelly Metzger for $35,000.

Joseph Santilli II and Wendy Gollnitz-Santilli sold 6710 Barden Road, Ripley to 6710 Barden Road LLC of Ridgefield, Conn. For $200,000.

Thomas and Ashley Pacheco sold 34 McDaniel Ave., Jamestown to Brian Goodrow for $65,000.

Shirley Ippolito sold 11994 Aldrich Road, Sheridan to Dalton and Jacqueline Coleman for $149,900.

James Ziemba and Dorothy Ziemba sold 82 Otter St., Dunkirk to Brittany Cerrie-Allen for $208,000.

Franjo Bozic sold 42 Cass St., Westfield to Richard Schroeder for $127,000.

Shaun Dowd sold 2431 Johnson Road, Charlotte to Judith Reynolds for $181,000.

Jeffrey and Sara Kim sold 2425 Lakeside Drive, Busti, to Ashville Cottage Company, LLC of Fairlawn, Ohio for $180,000.

Donald and Colleen Meder sold 6953 Barnes Road, Stockton to Seaboard Solar Holdings, LLC of New Milford, Conn. For $115,000.

84 Bennett Enterprise Inc. of Fredonia sold 10749 Bennett Road, Dunkirk to Recovery Real Estate Holdings LLC of Colchester, Vermont for $650,000.

Andrew Palaszewski sold 10203 Prospect Road, Hanover to Jacob Kumiega for $153,000.

Roberto Torres-Vega sold 623 West 8th St., Jamestown to Dustin Griffin for $600.

George Ekstrom sold 713 Warren Road, Frewsburg, town of Carroll, to Andrew Ekstrom for $85,000.

James and Paula Babcock sold property on Marvin Road, French Creek to Scott and Vicki Reynolds for $1,000.

Neftali and Aida DeJesus sold 438 Deer St., Dunkirk to Hector Reyes for $60,000. Reyes then sold that same property to Hugo Cardona for $120,000.

The Chautauqua County Land Bank sold 6 Cook Ave., Jamestown to Luther Lewis for $200.

Phineas and Sara DeMink sold 810 Hunt Road, Busti to Bryan and Marikate Calimeri for $189,900.

The executor of Randall Olson sold 32 Pearl Ave., Jamestown to Michael and Crystal Navarro for $20,000.

Steven and Rebecca Troyer sold 2667 Clymer Sherman Road, Sherman to Samuel and Verna Bender for $80,000.

The executor under the Last Will and Testament of Allan Hendrickson sold 503 W. 8th St., Jamestown to the Hendrickson Family 2019 Revocable Trust for $40,000.

Sharon Harless sold 8197 Sycamore Lane, Westfield to Juliann Travis and Stephen Baran for $36,500.

Richie Thompson and Carla Welka sold 3271 Rt. 5, Sheridan to Jessica Hari for $180,000

ZTS Residential Properties LLC of Tonawanda sold 720 Central Ave., Dunkirk to Kingpenny LLC of Elma, NY for $159,000.

Gregory Whitermore and Thomas Whitermore sold 35 Lakeview Ave., Jamestown to the Casey M. Oshay Reppas Living Trust for $165,000.

Daniel Miga sold 999 Central Ave., Dunkirk to Jacob Selig for $95,000.

James Messinger and Tammy Mook sold 292 State St., Jamestown to Willis Jr. and Darla Hayes for $112,000.

Miller & Clinton Development LLC of West Seneca sold 3350 Ames Road, Charlotte to Dennis and Penny Gullo for $55,000.

Jacqueline Wrigley sold 5588 South Ave., Van Buren Point, town of Portland, to Margaret Casey Thering and Dejadog LLC of San Francisco, Calif. for $292,000.

Richard Shick sold 3763 Westman Road, Ellery to Charles Shick for $190,000.

Matthew and Meghan Schatt sold 3732 Lakeland Ave., North Harmony to Robert Hinch and Rachel Winberg-Hinch $246,000.

Michael and Julie Vogle sold property on Warwick Road, Ellicott to Richard J. Benedetto Enterprises Inc. of Jamestown for $100.

Olivia Lee sold 55 N. Main St., Cassadaga to Marcus Lee for $70,000.

Daniel Tortorelli sold 103 Bowen St., Jamestown to Myra and Scott Feather for $46,000.

Ryan Przepasniak sold 111 Temple St., Fredonia to Michael and Mara Batson for $172,000.

Linda Netzel sold 8 Stoneman Ave., Lakewood to Spenser Soldano for $191,000.

Jack and Caryn Burgess sold 69 Elm St., Westfield to Brianna Hunt and Jacob Alonge for $130,000.

Lynn Langworthy sold 128 Maple St., Jamestown to Lisa Peterson and Barry Bailey for $87,000.

Allegany-Erie Inc. of Dunkirk sold 211 West Point Ave., Dunkirk to West Grove Road, LLC of Oradell, NJ for $2.4 million.

84 North Lake LLC of Cleveland, Ohio sold 84 North Lake Drive, Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua to Mollie Baker Merchant for $2.4 million.

Richard Rogers sold 9466 Lake Ave., Portland to Russel and Sherry Rusiski for $72,000.

Glen Terrance Solomonson sold 12 Fairmount Ave., Lakewood to Rapturn LLC of Lakewood for $120,000.

Vincent Bomasuto Jr. sold 317 Lord St., Dunkirk to Jiali Huang for $90,000.

Nicholas Coletta sold property on North Road, Pomfret to Forestville Dev LLC of Forestville for $31,455.

Robert and Susan Vasko sold 16 and 18 Front St., Silver Creek to 16 & 18 Front St., LLC of Buffalo for $322,000.