Real estate sales include south county restaurants
A Lakewood fast-food business has a new property management company, while a couple of nearby restaurants have new owners running them.
The Post-Journal and OBSERVER have been analyzing real estate sales in Chautauqua County and recently looked at the sales from Oct. 21-31.
During this time period, Chautauqua Mall Realty Holding, LLC of Great Neck, NY sold 318 Fairmount Ave., Lakewood to Paramount Investment Group, LLC Compton, Calif. for $1.2 million. A document in the sale calls the property an “outparcel” for Taco Bell.
In the town of Busti, there were two other restaurants that have new owners.
Debra Schuyler sold 4477 West Fairmount Ave. as well as lots of 4th St. and 5th St. Busti, to CHQ Ventures, LLC of Williamsville for $450,000. This is the location of Schuyler’s Country Kitchen. On Nov. 2, the owners of Lake Life Cafe in Bemus Point announced on Facebook that they are the new owners of Schuyler’s Kitchen in Lakewood. “We are so excited to continue on Deb’s legacy at this amazing establishment,” they wrote.
Christine Fosberg sold 792 Busti-Sugar Grove Road, Busti to MSSC Development, LLC of Falconer for $130,000. This is the location of Busti Tap House. On Oct. 25, the Busti Tap House announced on Facebook that new management was taking over the establishment. It officially reopened to the public on Jan. 24.
Another established business that has new ownership is the Bemus Point Market. John and Ruth Marsh sold 12 Main St., Bemus Point, to Food for Bemus, LLC of Ashville for $430,000. On Facebook, Bemus Point Market announced Dec. 31 that they were under new ownership. After being closed in January, the business reopened Feb. 1.
In Jamestown, a former restaurant has a new use. Jamestown Regional Properties, LLC of Mayville sold 235 Fluvanna Ave., Jamestown to North Eastern Equipment Sales and Rentals, LLC of Olean for $75,000. This is the former location of The Eatery. The building is now North Eastern Equipment Sales & Rentals, Inc.
Including the sales previously mentioned from Oct. 21-31 there were nine sales that were $250,000 or higher. The remaining top sales are as follows:
– 2706 Sunnyside Road, Mina sold for $520,000.
– 9 Crawford Lane, Lakewood sold for $389,000.
– St. Elmo Condominium Unit No. 305, 1 N. Pratt Ave., Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua sold for $380,000.
– 4406 W. Lake Road, Unit 26, Chautauqua town sold for $319,130.
– 7798 Aldrich Hill Road, Cherry Creek sold for $316,000.
– 10 Peck Ave., Chautauqua Institution sold for $270,000.
Overall, from Oct. 21-31 there were 133 transactions total. The full list of sales higher than $1 are as follows:
OCT. 23-27
Morgan Zollman and Matthew Dinger sold 6 Case Ave., Lakewood to Melanie and Randy Spokane for $230,000.
Mary and Patrick Tyler sold Lot 19 Hazzard St., Jamestown to Todd and Deana Hilenbrant for $5,000.
James and Julie Clinger sold 10 Peck Ave., Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, for $270,000.
Jamestown Regional Properties, LLC of Mayville sold 235 Fluvanna Ave., Jamestown to North Eastern Equipment Sales and Rentals, LLC of Olean for $75,000.
David Militello sold 12799 Pleasant Ave., town of Hanover to C&D Cottages, LLC of Irving for $75,000.
Christine Fosberg sold 792 Busti-Sugar Grove Road, Busti to MSSC Development, LLC of Falconer for $130,000.
MSSC Development, LLC of Falconer sold 4061 Gerry-Kimball Stand Road, Gerry to BPT Holdings, LLC of Jamestown for $130,000.
Marcus Stendahl sold 44 Harris Ave., Jamestown to Julia Speadling for $78,500.
William Young sold 7798 Aldrich Hill Road, Cherry Creek to Kevyn and Dominique Nelson for $316,000.
Paul Mercer sold 2269 Marlow Road, Ellicott for $190,500. The sale includes six parcels in Ellicott and one parcel in Jamestown.
Kyle and Ciara Shults sold 3725 County Road 52, Ellery to James and Eileen Klubek for $92,500.
Northeast Property Partners, LLC of Angola sold 12 Jefferson St., Westfield to Betts Apartments, LLC of Westfield for $31,000.
John Bell and Carol Vanepps sold 4079 Belleview Road, Ellery to John Paul Martha Jr. for $160,000.
John and Ruth Marsh sold 12 Main St., Bemus Point to Food for Bemus, LLC of Ashville for $430,000.
Uthumporn Noithanom sold 64 W. 14th St., Jamestown to William Soto for $10,000 and 3 Vega St., Jamestown for $10,000.
MFN Enterprises, LLC of Jamestown sold 1101 Prendergast Ave., Jamestown to William Soto for $2,000.
Christopher Veres sold 7 Orchard St., Jamestown to Brian Closs for $15,000.
Raymond and Dawn Pratt sold 742 Versailles Road, Hanover to Jeremy and Kathryn Pratt for $185,000.
Jean Rae Erskine sold 669 Rt. 83, Villenova to Richard Zehr and William Young for $142,000.
Gary and Lillian Botham sold 568 Bentley Hill Road, Ellington to Dan Hostetler for $114,900.
Teresa Stevens sold 19 Gerald Ave., Jamestown to James Rauh and Jillian Shults for $40,000.
The village of Sherman sold 121 and 123 W. Main St., Sherman to M3P Realty, LLC of Fredonia for $35,000.
Kings Royal Properties, LLC of Falconer sold 140 S. Work St., Falconer to MSSC Development, LLC for $90,000.
Rosalyn Young sold 4406 W. Lake Road, Unit 26, Chautauqua town, to Terry and Mary Kreuz for $319,130.
Paul and Dana Baker sold a parcel on East Central Ave., Westfield to Pines Investment Group LTD of Sewickley, Pa. for $25,000.
A referee for Matthew Wilson sold 1866 Thornton Road, Charlotte to M&T Bank for $116,847.
Leslie West sold 400 E. Terrace Ave., Lakewood to Lawrence DeLong for $70,000. DeLong sold that address to Chautauqua Area Development, LLC of Jamestown for $50,000.
Esther Muencz, Stevan Ganz and William Ganz sold a parcel on Erwin Road, Cherry Creek to John Johnson for $19,500.
Ronald and Kathy Dennison sold 431 Hallock St., Jamestown to Teresa Stevens for $59,700.
Trustees of the Karen L. Middaugh Trust sold St. Elmo Condominium Unit No. 305, 1 N. Pratt Ave., Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua to David Szabo and Melodie Wing for $380,000.
Cole and Elizabeth Gleason sold 9800 Brownell Road, French Creek to Todd and Dawna Hulslander for $225,000.
The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Allen Ecker sold 9153 North Hill Road, Villenova to Trenton Leverentz for $130,000.
William Soto sold 10 Colfax St., Jamestown to HomesfromHolmes, LLC of Jamestown for $10,000.
Philip Johnson sold 110 Stowe St., Jamestown to TH Capital Partners, LLC of Jamestown for $10,000.
Cheap Lands Inc. of Port St. Lucie, Fla. sold 37 Westcott St., Jamestown to Mary Rodriguez Betancourt for $3,600.
Chautauqua Mall Realty Holding, LLC of Great Neck, NY sold 318 Fairmount Ave., Lakewood to Paramount Investment Group, LLC of Compton, Calif. for $1.2 million.
Frederick Santucci, Mary Santucci, Bridget Copel and Molly Marhofer sold 2879 W. Oak Hill Road, Ellicott to Nerissa Joyce L. Trinidad for $199,900.
Adam Cady sold 114 Lakeside Blvd., Ellicott to James Treadway and Jason Jarmusz for $222,900.
Terrill Johnson sold 63 Grant St., Jamestown to TH Capital Partners, LLC of Jamestown for $10,000.
Luke and Kathleen Peterson sold 137 Big Tree Sugar Grove Road, Busti to Tatyn Tyo Bryant for $95,000.
A trustee of the Dominique Forbes Cherau Irrevocable Family Trust sold 106 Liberty St., Fredonia to Laura Horn for $123,000.
Donald and Mary Farley sold 2706 Sunnyside Road, Mina to Gregory J. King and Elizabeth M. King for $520,000.
Ellen Franklin sold 6594 Woeben Road, Portand to Darleen and Paul Gouveia for $185,000.
Christopher and Shannon White sold 761 Southside Ave., Cherry Creek to 761 Southside Trust of Cherry Creek for $175,000.
Brenda Nelson sold 48 W. Chadakoin St., Celoron for $97,000.
Crystal Waterhouse sold 680 Southside Ave., Cherry Creek to 680 Southside Trust of Cherry Creek for $6,700.
The administrator of the Estate of Barbara Olson sold 14 Charles St., Frewsburg, town of Carroll, to Emily Foy for $137,000.
John Walsh sold 179 Chestnut St., Westfield to Joseph and Ellen Golubski for $140,000.
James Magee sold 18 Flagg St., Jamestown to NT Property Rentals, LLC of Lakewood for $45,000.
A trustee of the Marilyn Elliott Family Trust sold a parcel on Route 430, Ellery to Terry and Laurie Norris for $2,800.
David and Marjorie Switala sold 9 Crawford Lane, Lakewood to Charles Short, Constance Short and Julie Lundstad for $389,000.
Samuel and Julie Giaimo sold a parcel on Sherman Road, Westfield to Jessie and Kelly Eschenbach for $8,000.
Emily Larson sold 118 Ivory St., Frewsburg to George Giambrone for $148,294.
Eileen Beichner, Brian Abram and Shawn Abram sold 38 Dale Drive, Stockton to Seth and Richard Marcantonio for $245,000.
The Anthony Butekoff Family Revocable Trust sold 4031 Shore Acres Drive, Ellery to Christina Elia and Elizabeth Reinig for $73,000.
Butekoff Associate LLC of Pittsburgh, Pa. sold 4035 Shore Acres Drive, Ellery to Christina Elia and Elizabeth Reinig for $305,000.
The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Ronald J. Rys sold 27 E. Doughty St., Dunkirk to Carmen Ivette Melendez for $96,500.
OCT. 30-31
The administrator of the Estate of Gloria Stolinski sold 40 Genet St., Dunkirk to Paul Joshua O’Brocta for $115,000.
Judith Kahabka and Kimberly Granata sold 3758 Wildwood Drive, Dunkirk town to Michael Allen for $200,000.
Gary Vance sold 514 Jefferson St., Jamestown to Christine Setari for $51,000.
James Lewis Jr. sold a parcel on Route 430, Mina to Rak Properties, LLC of Erie, Pa. for $23,500.
Daniel and Ruthie Burkholder sold a parcel on Clymer Hill and Ravlin Hill, Clymer to Jacob and Fannie Leslein for $30,000.
Andrew and Kristan Garvey sold 25 Pershing Ave., Jamestown to Michael Thompson for $125,000.
Betty Otander sold 34 E. Fifth St., Ellicott to Meredith Mactavish for $87,500.
Debra Schuyler sold 11 lots on West Fairmount Ave., 4th St. and 5th St. Busti, to CHQ Ventures, LLC of Williamsville for $450,000.
A trustee with the Sally B. Gollmann Living Trust sold Unit No. 7 in Building No. K of the Edgewater Recreation Condominium, 907 Edgewater Drive, Westfield to Jason Reed and Michele DePhilip for $150,000.
Douglas Diers sold 6031 Johnson Road, Charlotte to Kolby Parks for $130,000.
David Peterson sold 420 Camp St., Jamestown to David Bergstrom for $33,000.
Duane and Julie Mills sold a parcel on Peck Settlement Road, Ellicott to Cody Latimer for $28,000.
Caroline Adamson sold 5585-5591 Eke Road, North Harmony to Bridgette Maynes for $157,000.
Ralph Ferro sold 49 Castile Drive, Fredonia to Deborah and Jake Barmore for $125,000.
Gerry Johnson and Nancy Bender sold 252 Ivy St., Jamestown to Susan Leonard and Mark McCannon for $140,000.
The executor of the Estate of Nelle L. Cala sold 301 E. 8th St., Jamestown to Raven Corvus for $127,500.
Stacy DiCara Bonnett, Charles DiCara, and Joseph DiCara sold 12 Crooked Brook Drive, Dunkirk to Stacy Thrasher for $130,000.
Garrett Hicks sold 502 Newland Ave., Jamestown to 441 W1st St AZ, LLC of Tucson, Ariz. for $74,999.
Janet Preston sold 10150 Lakeview Ave., Mina to Kenneth Kramer Jr. and Jessica Farrell for $47,000.
Stanley Glenda L. Barber sold 2841 East Ave., Ellery to Eric and Krystle Haglund for $132,000.
Liliana Arranz sold 114 Broadhead Ave., Jamestown to 441 W1st St AZ, LLC of Tucson, Ariz. for $98,000.
Mark and Cara Abbey sold 6468 Nelson Road, Charlotte to Cody Johnson for $127,000.
Clifton and Co. Property Group, LLC of Buffalo sold 132 Fairview Ave., Jamestown to David Attard for $30,000.